Version 1 (modified by cowan, 4 years ago) (diff)


The Scheme standards say that a one-armed if returns an unspecified value if the first argument is false. The great majority of all Schemes tested have an "unspecified value" value, which is returned as the value of (if #f #f) and in other circumstances where the standards say that the value is unspecified. The printing of this value is often suppressed by the REPL. The following are exceptions:

(if #f #f) => #f: Bigloo, JScheme, Dream, Owl Lisp

(if #f #f) => (): NexJ, TinyScheme, Elk, UMB, Llava, Dfsch, Inlab

(if #f #f) => #t: Shoe, FemtoLisp

(if #f #f) => a value which is both #f and (): XLisp, Rep

SXM returns a closure which when invoked apparently loops forever.

Note that although R6RS allows returning an unspecified number of unspecified values, including no values, no known Scheme implementation actually does so.